Default Liberty
A Theory of Derived Constraint
A source-first theory of liberty, authority, and derived constraint.
Liberty is the default.
Constraint is not primitive. Whoever asserts one must derive it from a valid source, through an identifiable mechanism and trigger, and it reaches no farther than the derivation supports.
Recent Writing
All writingThe Reach of a Signature
A wall needs rebuilding. One association vote binds Helen to pay. Another cannot open her backyard.
Read the articleWhat the Members Gave
A workshop can give its members real governing powers. What happens when a vote reaches beyond the grant?
Read the articleA Right Is Not a Court
Theo's tires are slashed and his solar panel is damaged. Even if compensation is owed, what gives a court the authority to compel the person accused to appear?
Read the articleHow the System Works
A change to a person's position runs from the position they already hold, through a source and the facts that trigger it, to one exact relation with a ceiling on its reach. Everything after that is a further question.
The chain in full- Prior positionLiberty, or another position already validly held.
- Source or mechanismAn accepted source, or a valid act within it.
- TriggerThe proven facts that activate it.
- Hohfeldian positionThe exact relation created, and its ceiling.
Downstream stages
- 5Violation
- 6Liability
- 7Jurisdiction
- 8Procedure
- 9Remedy
- 10Enforcement
A violation is not yet a liability. A liability is not jurisdiction. Jurisdiction does not authorize every procedure or settle the remedy, and a remedy is not its own enforcement. Each stage needs a source that reaches it.
If a link fails, the derivation stops there. The prior position remains.
Newsletter
Ongoing essays, project developments, worked examples and public research commentary go out by Substack. This website remains the permanent home of the theory; the newsletter is distribution.
Subscribe on SubstackThis page creates no doctrine. The project's canon controls.