About the project
Default Liberty is a jurisprudential design project. It develops and stress-tests a theory of where constraint comes from, and tries to state that theory precisely enough to be checked.
Written for this site from the project's accepted materials. It creates no doctrine. Canon controls.
What it is
The project asks how little foundational authority a normative order can assume while still supporting contracts, property, firms, associations, care for people who cannot decide for themselves, tribunals, remedies and enforcement. Its answer is a small closed set of sources, a short grammar for building further authority from them, and a rule that every constraint must be traceable to a source that actually reaches it.
The foundation does not supply any of those institutions ready-made. A tribunal, a remedy or a means of enforcement exists only where someone has validly constituted it, on a source that reaches the person and the matter, and only within that source's scope.
It is research and design, not advocacy. The work is to reason forward from stated premises, take the results seriously, and record where they are uncomfortable or incomplete.
What it is not
The theory is a proposed architecture. It does not describe existing law, and it does not claim that any existing court, legislature, community or institution is constituted under its sources, or that anyone is bound by its internal procedures.
It does not claim to have proved its own moral premises. The foundational sources are choices, stated openly so that they can be challenged, and the project keeps a record of the strongest objections to them.
Nothing on this site is legal advice. It says nothing about what the law of any jurisdiction requires of you.
The name
The theory was developed under the working name Bounded Normative Authority (BNA). Earlier files and one of the diagrams on this site still carry that label. The change of name was expository. It changed no doctrine.
How the site relates to the theory
The theory lives in a set of governing documents, the canon, maintained under the review process described on the Canon page. This website presents that work. It creates no doctrine, and where it differs from the canon, the canon controls. Each page says what kind of thing it is: a text reproduced verbatim with its version and hash, an exposition written for the site, or research that is not accepted doctrine.
How Default Liberty is developed
Default Liberty is developed through a provenance-controlled research system. The system applies to the research the same source-first discipline the theory applies to normative authority. Canonical commitments are kept separate from research candidates, external scholarship, and software-generated analysis. Before a new proposition can alter the accepted theory, it is reconstructed from its claimed sources, stress-tested, and separately reviewed.
The project uses an explicit derivational chain, dedicated retrieval and Codex infrastructure, immutable research records, and a separate Evidence process to make dependencies and changes inspectable. These tools assist the research. They do not determine normative validity, and they do not modify the theory on their own.
Author
Dan Merchant is an independent researcher, writer, and systems designer. His work spans normative theory, institutional authority, artificial intelligence, and formal systems. He created Default Liberty: A Theory of Derived Constraint, a source-first jurisprudential framework. Its central proposition is that liberty is the prior position, and that anyone who claims a constraint displacing it must derive that constraint from an identifiable source, a trigger, and a bounded chain of authority.
Merchant is also the founder of FoundryOS, where he works on AI-assisted systems, evidence architecture, automation, and tools that make complex reasoning and operational processes easier to inspect. That systems work informs Default Liberty’s insistence on derivational transparency. A conclusion should be reconstructable, authority should not be smuggled from one stage to the next, and a downstream power has to be established on its own rather than assumed.
His current work includes the Default Liberty public and scholarly publications, and the planned formal derivational ledger and Default Liberty Derivation Lab.
How to cite
The published texts are versioned snapshots. Later changes to the canon can supersede parts of an earlier snapshot without altering it, so cite the version you read. Each text's page gives its version and the SHA-256 of its source file.
Public articles:
Dan Merchant. “The Reach of a Signature.” Default Liberty: A Theory of Derived Constraint, Public Article 1 R1.1. https://defaultliberty.org/writing/the-reach-of-a-signature/ Source SHA-256 fd388a3d3bc47c52b21fe6c7ac7b776672a045c85c060f509364e6d6724054a3.
Dan Merchant. “What the Members Gave.” Default Liberty: A Theory of Derived Constraint, Public Article 2 R1.1. https://defaultliberty.org/writing/what-the-members-gave/ Source SHA-256 93cf7ef1f8d40da6669bdb54838b2675b4591d37f847e93ceeb078789ed3806c.
Dan Merchant. “A Right Is Not a Court.” Default Liberty: A Theory of Derived Constraint, Public Article 3 Reconciled R1. https://defaultliberty.org/writing/a-right-is-not-a-court/ Source SHA-256 0c9ad56ff1482c95bfe1eead41f635fcfa6bed270d7567848ce0c46044c8c8dc.
The reader guide:
Dan Merchant. “A Short Guide for Readers.” Default Liberty: A Theory of Derived Constraint, Reader-Facing Short Guide R2, snapshot of 2026-09-30. https://defaultliberty.org/theory/guide/
The project as a whole:
Dan Merchant. Default Liberty: A Theory of Derived Constraint. https://defaultliberty.org/
Contact
Essays and project updates go out by Substack.