Research

Where the sources run out

The theory is built to be able to say that a power has not been established. This page lists the places where it currently says so, and the objections it has not answered away.

NONCANONICAL RESEARCH

Nothing on this page is accepted doctrine. It reports the project's own classification of unresolved questions. A listing here creates no presumption that a rule will follow, and none of these questions is resolved by being described.

Research programs

Three lines of work are active. Each is research, and none has produced a change to the canon.

  • Is the foundation as small as it could be?

    Noncanonical research

    Four hypotheses are under adversarial review: that residual liberty is a corollary of the priority of liberty; that emergency non-override is a theorem and not a root; that the no-smuggling rules partly reduce to something simpler; and that release is a deeper relative of waiver. None is an established redundancy. Removing or merging anything foundational would itself require foundational revision.

  • Can an organization hold positions in its own right?

    Noncanonical research

    Durable holding by an entity, the partition of its assets, the turnover of its members, and limited liability toward strangers cannot be assumed from organizational status. The project treats this as a material gap that is derivative, not fatal.

  • A formal record of derivations

    Noncanonical research

    Whether the architecture can be represented as a graph and ledger without the software deciding normative questions. Accepted as a research roadmap only. See the Lab.

No candidate proposals are currently published on this site.

Open questions

Open

Most of these were deliberately left unresolved when the foundation was last revised, and the neighbouring rules were drawn so as not to decide them indirectly. Until one is settled by valid derivation or amendment, the answer is that the claimed position is not established and the prior position remains.

  • Whether a stranger may intervene for a person who is competent but physically unable to make a choice known.
  • Whether basic care can ever extend to a chosen, major, irreversible bodily alteration.
  • Exactly how far protections against killing, severe harm and the destruction of agency can be waived or given up.
  • Compulsory jurisdiction over strangers who have not accepted a forum.
  • The boundary of extreme but lawful pressure, including economic duress.
  • Whether physical impossibility limits the validity of a rule.
  • Whether an estate or other juridical entity can itself be a holder of positions.

Unsupported in general, open in a narrower form

Two matters carry both classifications. The broad position is not established on the current sources. What remains unresolved is whether anything narrower could be. Until that is settled by valid derivation or amendment, the prior position remains in both respects.

  • Defending a competent person who has not authorized it

    Unsupported No general liberty to defend a competent person without their authorization is established.

    Open Whether some narrower, differently triggered or separately sourced route to such a defense can be derived has not been settled.

  • Using another person’s resources out of necessity

    Unsupported No general privilege to take or use another person’s resources out of necessity is established.

    Open Whether some narrower, differently triggered or separately sourced route can be derived has not been settled.

Unsupported as general authority

Unsupported under current sources

Each of these is a power people commonly assume exists against anyone at all. The current sources do not establish any of them as a general position. That is not a permanent prohibition: participants can constitute narrower versions among themselves within their own powers, a later derivation may change the classification, and a genuinely new foundational source would require foundational revision.

  • Overriding the bodily claim of a person who poses a threat innocently.
  • Representative power for whoever arrives first, where no valid selection applies.
  • Detention or arrest after a violation has ended.
  • A universal power to execute a judgment or debt.
  • A general right, like intellectual property, to exclude strangers on the basis of authorship, creation or copying alone.
  • A distributive floor, or authority to redistribute.
  • An independent general authority to preserve ecosystems.
  • Strict liability toward strangers as a general default.
  • Punishment, punitive damages or general gain-stripping as automatic incidents of a wrong.

On research hold

Research hold

Questions set aside for further study and comparison. A hold creates no presumption of later doctrine.

  • A neutral forum tied to a claim, between strangers who have not consented to one.
  • Decisions for another person that are highly irreversible.
  • Repeated low-intensity contact, and the boundary of intimate contact.
  • Harms with several independently sufficient causes, and how they might be allocated.
  • How digital and cryptographic resources should be classified.
  • Commons, flowing resources and ecosystems.

Left to constituted systems

Much of what a legal system needs is not foundational at all. Validly constituted arrangements may settle these matters differently from one another, within their actual powers. Examples: standards of proof and evidence procedure; appeal, reopening and finality; public access and confidentiality; allocation of costs; insolvency, exemptions and priority among creditors; governance, deadlock and partition among co-holders; schedules and caps for non-pecuniary loss; ladders for selecting a representative; intestacy and family allocation.

That a matter is local is never itself a source, and a local rule never binds outsiders.

Objections the project records against itself

The foundational sources are explicit choices. The project has put each through external challenge, concluded that no objection reviewed so far requires foundational revision, and committed to carrying the objections openly instead of presenting the roots as uniquely compelled. That conclusion is the project's own assessment. The positions below are other people's, stated here as fairly as a summary allows. The works behind them are listed in the source notes.

  • Authority as service

    External · Raz

    On the service conception, expertise, coordination or better conformity to reasons can ground authority. Default Liberty does not currently accept any of these as self-validating. The project records this as a genuine rival architecture that it has not refuted.

  • Unilateral acquisition

    External · Kant, Ripstein

    One person’s acquisition of an unclaimed resource places duties on strangers who never agreed. Some public-right accounts allow provisional possession but require public, omnilateral completion before the right is conclusive. Default Liberty does not currently require that completion. The project regards this root as carrying its highest burden of external justification. A narrow trigger and bounded scope reduce the objection without eliminating it.

  • Emergencies and the innocent

    External · Lesser-evil and innocent-threat theories

    Lesser-evil and innocent-threat theories are serious rivals: on those views an emergency can justify what Default Liberty refuses. The refusal is a deliberate and contested choice. Its claim is the narrower one: emergency or aggregate benefit alone does not supply the missing permission.

  • Substitute decision-making

    External · CRPD Article 12

    Protective representation remains in real tension with the strongest reading of Article 12 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which opposes substitute decision-making. The theory’s defense rests on support first, incapacity assessed decision by decision, priority for the person’s will and preferences, valid selection of the representative, fiduciary purpose, minimum scope, review, and termination when the trigger ends. That does not erase the disagreement.

  • Disputes nobody can resolve

    External · Institutional nonresolution

    If jurisdiction needs a source, some disputes will have no forum with authority over both parties. The project accepts that this has serious practical costs, and prefers unresolved authority to authority invented from the need for coordination.

  • A closed foundation can be wrong

    External · Foundational contestability

    Closure controls how the foundation may change. It is not a guarantee that the foundation is true, and acceptance within the project is not philosophical proof.