How the canon is kept
A theory that asks every authority to show its source has to keep its own books. This page sets out what the project currently accepts, and the procedure by which anything is added or changed.
A summary written for this site from the project's governing documents. Website presentation does not itself establish canonical status. Where this page and the canon differ, the canon controls.
Four statuses
Every proposition in the project carries one of four statuses, and nothing moves between them silently. A persuasive argument, a repeated claim or a recent draft is still whatever status it was last given.
- ACCEPTED
Canonical. The proposition has completed the adoption sequence required for it and controls until validly changed. An accept decision on review is one step in that sequence and does not by itself make anything canonical.
- CANDIDATE
Proposed and under consideration. Not adopted, and not to be relied on as doctrine.
- OPEN
Unresolved. The current sources have not been shown to settle the question either way.
- SUPERSEDED
Rejected or replaced. Kept in the record so that it is not revived by accident.
Unresolved questions are sorted further: some are open to derivation, some are unsupported on the current foundation, some are left to particular constituted systems, and some are held for research. Those lists are on the Research page, which is kept visibly separate from this one.
The foundational source set
Ten sources, and the set is closed. No further root may be implied from convention, emergency, institutional status, a desired outcome or the capacity to enforce.
Rules of derivation
Liberty–obligation primacy
Any position that displaces liberty must arise from an accepted source or a valid derivation, and extends no further than its source and trigger support.
Residual liberty
Where no source and trigger establish an alteration, the prior position remains.
Foundational closure
The set of foundational sources is closed. Nothing is added by implication; new foundational content requires explicit revision.
No smuggling
Whoever asserts a position proves its source, trigger, content and scope, and the derivation must be open to inspection. No unstated premise may do hidden work.
Substantive starting points
Normative subjecthood
Persons are normative subjects. Standing does not depend on present competence.
Embodied agency
No one has a default liberty intentionally to strike, seize, restrain, confine, compel the movement of, directly injure or comparably use another person's body without valid authorization or another independent basis.
Resource acquisition
Genuinely unclaimed resources can be claimed through bounded, peaceful, identifiable control or use sufficient for a coherent resource project. Property creates no sovereignty over other people.
Serious avoidable bodily risk
No one has a default liberty to create or materially increase a substantial, reasonably identifiable risk of serious bodily injury when the accepted trigger is met.
Emergency non-override
Emergency or aggregate benefit alone does not erase an innocent person's embodied-agency claim.
Protective representation
Decision-specific incapacity supports only a bounded fiduciary power, under the accepted trigger and a valid selection of the representative. Status alone creates no authority.
The constitutive grammar
Within those sources, people change normative positions through five ordinary acts. They are distinct primitives, and naming one does not perform a different one.
Consent or waiver
A person permits conduct that would otherwise violate a claim, or waives the claim, within the valid scope of that permission.
Undertaking
A person validly takes on an obligation.
Authorization or delegation
A person gives another a bounded power, without necessarily transferring the underlying position.
Release or discharge
A person with the relevant power narrows or extinguishes an existing claim or obligation.
Assignment
The holder of a transferable position is substituted, without enlarging the position.
Larger structures are composites of these: joining an existing arrangement, forum clauses, the constitutions of service providers, security interests, advance directives, and the governance of common resources.
A few mechanisms are classed as special: protection triggered by a violation, protective representation, restoration, compensation, and constitutional change. Each operates only on its own accepted source and trigger.
One rule runs through all of it. A constituted power cannot bootstrap its own authority.
After a violation
Establishing a duty and its breach settles less than it seems to. Obligation, liability, jurisdiction, remedy and enforcement are five different things, and each needs a source that reaches it.
An institution's competence does not by itself alter anyone's position. Presence, residence, citizenship, majority support, benefits received, convention, history, territory, control, market dominance, state status and the capacity to enforce are not self-validating. An adjudicator finds boundaries and does not legislate them, and the merits of a claim cannot create jurisdiction to hear it.
Restoration and compensation are accepted as secondary liabilities, and a remedy goes no further than the least intervention sufficient for what was proven. Punishment, punitive damages, general disgorgement, general detention and a universal power to execute judgments remain unsupported unless separately justified.
The Fidelity Gate
Every proposed root, mechanism, doctrine, institutional power or remedy must state the same nine things, in order. The order matters. Nothing downstream is considered until the primary position is established and bounded.
- Prior position. The baseline liberty, or the valid position already in place.
- Alteration. Exactly what is proposed to change.
- Source. The accepted source or valid mechanism relied on.
- Trigger facts. The facts that must be proven for the source to operate.
- Hohfeldian result. The precise relation produced, and between whom.
- Scope ceiling. The furthest the source and facts can carry it.
- No-smuggling audit. A check that no unaccepted premise is doing hidden work.
- Residual liberty. What remains unaltered.
- Downstream. Only then: violation, liability, jurisdiction, procedure, remedy and enforcement, each on its own source.
Closure, and how the foundation changes
Closure is a rule about sources. It says what can count as a foundational source and forbids adding one by interpretation. It does not say the theory has a positive rule for every dispute, and it does not say the foundation is morally proven. Some positions are established, some questions remain open, some claims are unsupported, and the foundation itself may turn out to need correcting.
Correction has two tracks. Ordinary amendments refine and develop rules within the existing foundation. Foundational revision is mandatory for anything that adds, removes or materially changes a root, or that touches subjecthood, the priority of liberty, closure, the power to ratify, or the amendment rule itself. Where it is doubtful which track applies, the doubt resolves to foundational revision.
Either way the sequence is fixed: an exact proposal, the Fidelity Gate, acceptance by the separate internal Evidence review, explicit ratification after that acceptance, a hash-guarded promotion into the governing documents, and promulgation. A failure at any stage leaves the earlier position controlling. The foundation was revised this way to add the narrow rules on basic care, third-party stoppage and preserved exit.
All of this is internal to the theory. The amendment procedure gives the project no jurisdiction over anyone in the world.
Two lanes
The Method page sets out the working architecture in full. In outline:
Work on the theory is split so that no one accepts their own proposal. The research lane derives, stress-tests and drafts, and publishes its results as fixed checkpoints. It cannot mark anything accepted.
The evidence lane takes one checkpoint at a time, verifies the sources it cites, checks the derivation, the objections and the hard cases, and records exactly one disposition: accept, reject, supersede, or return for work. Acceptance does not itself change the canon. Promotion is a separate, explicit step, and nothing in the process is automatic.
Research begins from the inside. The first question is what follows from the accepted sources, attempted without importing outside doctrine. If the derivation fails, the prior position is preserved or the gap is classified. Only then is external scholarship brought in, for objections, analogues, counterexamples and terminology. An external solution to a gap does not become the missing source.
When documents disagree, the order of authority is the project state, then the canonical doctrine documents, then the decision record, then accepted review records, then research history.
Authority effect: none
Four kinds of thing are routinely mistaken for authority and have none.
Publications
Articles, the reader guide, the monograph and the one-page visual explain the canon. Acceptance of a text for publication is a judgment about fidelity, not a grant of authority.
This website
Display order, emphasis, navigation and wording here establish nothing.
External scholarship
Doctrine, statutes, case law, prestige and consensus are used to test and challenge the theory. They do not become sources by citation.
Software and records
Retrieval tools, formal specifications, hashes, signatures, ledgers and machine validation can represent a derivation. None of them can supply one.